A more consistent definition of tetration of tetration for rational exponents
#11
bo198214 Wrote:It is in the same sense arbitrary as say that I define
\( {}^{1/n}x=1 \). No rule justifies that \( {}^{1/n}x \) should be the inverse of \( {}^nx \).

Let me try to explain the "obvious" rule behind such a definition. Call the inverse operator of multiplication @t. Then the inverse of multiplication must satisfy:

\( (x*n)@t=x \)

consequently it is easily seen that \( @t=*(1/n) \), which is the only operator which fits the bill. Similarly, call the inverse operator of exponentiation @@k. Then the inverse of exponentiation must satisfy:

\( (x^n)@@k=x \)

consequently it is esily seen that \( @@k={\^}(1/n) \), which is the only operator which fits the bill. Again similarly, call the inverse operator of tetration @@@m. Then the inverse of tetration must satisfy:

\( (@@@m)({^n}x)=x \)

from which it follows that \( @@@m= \)tetraroot of order n of x, since the tetraroot is the only operator which satisfies:

\( (tetraroot-n)(^{n}x)=x \)

Now, the very subtle problem which I guess nobody sees (for some strange reason) is that if the operator for tetrating to (1/n) *is NOT* the same operator as that of the tetraroot of order n, then we have an operator discrepancy at a very low level in the hierarchy of operators:

\( {^{1/n}}({^{n}x)=/= x \)

I am not going to argue more about it. Whoever "sees" it, great. Whoever doesn't, great again.Smile

bo198214 Wrote:If you not even demand that \( {}^xe \) is continuous, what will then remain?
Sorry, "demanding" and "constructing" are not the same as "existing". Besides, there's no teling whether tetration as defined using tetraroots is or is not continuous.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
RE: A more consistent definition of tetration of tetration for rational exponents - by UVIR - 09/30/2007, 10:29 PM

Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  A very special set of tetration bases marcokrt 3 5,947 03/14/2026, 01:43 PM
Last Post: marcokrt
  extending normal tetration to real numbers using product tetration Alex Zuma 2025 0 935 12/12/2025, 07:49 PM
Last Post: Alex Zuma 2025
  Tetration with complex bases TetrationSheep 0 747 11/13/2025, 10:33 AM
Last Post: TetrationSheep
  i have a seemingly reasonable definition for tetration Alex Zuma 2025 0 887 10/19/2025, 04:00 PM
Last Post: Alex Zuma 2025
  product tetration Alex Zuma 2025 0 1,204 09/24/2025, 12:47 PM
Last Post: Alex Zuma 2025
  Fractional tetration method Koha 2 6,053 06/05/2025, 01:40 AM
Last Post: Pentalogue
Question Tetration using the integral Pentalogue 0 4,260 05/27/2025, 11:27 PM
Last Post: Pentalogue
  Not about tetration but what do you think about this paper? Ansus 4 5,892 04/12/2025, 07:32 AM
Last Post: Ansus
  A question about tetration from a newbie TetrationSheep 2 6,269 08/26/2024, 12:38 PM
Last Post: TetrationSheep
  Two types of tetration : sexp ' > or < 1. tommy1729 3 7,962 10/17/2023, 12:06 PM
Last Post: tommy1729



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)